Emails About My Website
by Philip Guo (philip@pgbovine.net)
General Emails
From Montreal, Canada (2002-02-01):
Hi Philip, I'm a computer programmer from Montreal, Canada and just came across your homepage and really liked your pics. Take photograhs my hobby too. [...]
From Singapore (2003-09-27):
My name is XXXXXX from Singapore. Just hope you won't feel so surprise for reading this note. Basically, I was just taking a break and was browsing through the cyberspace after I was done with my thesis and just happened to come across your web site on photography. And found them very interesting and was thinking of dropping u a note. I know it may seemed a bit awkward but anyway, I've hit the send button, guess its irreversible. :) [...]
From New York, New York, USA (2004-02-19):
Hi, Philip I was happened to be on your site and enjoying reading the articles and your photo, very impressive design and layout. I have signed your guestbook, and wish to be informed with any update. [...]
From unknown location (2005-03-04):
Dear Philip, I stumbled upon your website while perusing the Internet (I was looking for articles on film vs. digital cameras). As a mother and teacher, I must tell you that I was profoundly impressed by your excellent writing skills, your extraordinary maturity for one so young, and your wonderful sense of visual beauty. I, too, was the valedictorian of my high school graduating class (back in the Dark Ages) and considering the dearth of talent and standards that has come about over the years, it is very encouraging to observe the accomplishments of such a fine, young man. Use what you have to serve. Money and success will always come to someone like you, but happiness could escape you if you don't give back. In the end, it's all that really matters. Best of luck. XXXXXX
From Ireland (2005-07-16):
Hey!!!!!! How are you doing? i just read ur articules from the website!! they are interesing. i dont know if this is ur only email that i can have contact to you, do u have any other? bye XXXXXX
From Northern Ireland (2005-11-15):
Hi Philip I came accross your site after doing a search for xml photo gallery - not because I knew it existed but because those were the keywords to describe what I wanted to build! I'm desiging a website for a friend who is an artist and instead of the usual html photo presentations I really like the idea of making it dynamic (for updating later when he has new art to show) so naturally, having used XML before for a music player. an XML solution seemed best. [...] Anyway, before I forget - thanks for a great, informative and interesting site. I feel you have a lot of intelligence and talent and just the right mixture of scientific intrigue and artistic bent to really make things of value for others and yourself - be they entertainment or functional. And not only that you have a good spirit to want to share what you've learned to make it easier for others. Not many are so selfless in our present world. - thanks. I've no doubt you will go a long way (if Armageddon doesn't get here first and ruin it for you :-) [...] Keep up the good work Philip. Continue to enjoy your education and continue to share it with others Thank you. I send you kind regards from Northern Ireland. XXXXXX P.S I'm a firm believer in sharing - indeed I give songs away free on my site. But I also believe in credit where credit is due so I'm happy to pay a donation to sites where I get some software/info etc that save me time. Might I suggest you have a PayPal donation button on your site so those who benefit from your sharing might have the oppertunity to thank you? You may not make a living from the donations but whatever amount comes in, it can help toward the maintainence of your website.
From Mexico (2006-02-07):
Hi, I was on your website and I wanted to tell you that I'm thankful with your sharing articles... and I think that you're a very good photographer too. Have a nice day! Saludos y ¡buen día! XXXXXX
From Cambridge, Massachusetts, USA (2006-08-21):
hi Philip, I randomly ran into your personal webpage this morning and have enjoyed reading your site. Thanks for all the writings/tips! They are really fun to read. Congrats on all your accomplishments and best of luck to you at Standford :)
From Evanston, Illinois, USA (2006-11-10):
I can't help but browse, and I must say, I like your choice of 10 pt Verdana. I don't think 12 pt looks that great and visually appealing things always encourages perusal. :)
From Stanford, California, USA (2006-12-29):
Hi Philip - Did you know that your website is the #4 result for NDSEG on google? Crazy. I just stumbled across it and wanted to let you know that your writings section was interesting and useful to me. Cheers - XXXXXX
From the Philippines (2007-12-29):
Hi Philip! I was browsing the net about the 6.170 MIT Probset when I saw your site. I read most of your articles in the site and it was really good. I had fun and it keeps me relax while doing the probset (yeah, on a christmas break). Thanks! ^^ I learned a lot from your articles, and I hope you'll write more of your ideas and experiences that will really inspire other people. Thanks again! ^__^ ~~XXXXXX
From unknown location (2008-03-08):
i came across the photo of (what i think is) your bulldog, when i did a google image search for "bulldog". honestly, it is ADORABLE. it is now my desktop photo and i can't stop looking at it! you're an awesome photographer! - XXXXXX
From unknown location (2008-03-11):
Hi, I ran across your website during lunch (looking for weird animals) and thought you might like to know more about the "round butted black-white animal" in your Winter 2005 : San Diego gallery. It is a Malayan Tapir. Just thought I would share some of the useless knowledge I have stored in my brain. I might forget who I am from time to time but I know what a Tapir is. LOL XXXXXX :o) by SLLiew The Malayan Tapir is an ancient animal, much unchanged since the evolution of mammals. It is black and white. Saw it in the wild for the first time in Taman Negara at 3am in the morning from a viewing hide over a salt lick. At first, we just saw the red eyes and thought it was a panther. Then the entire white body outline revealling that it was a tapir, a gentle herbivore. What is significant is the tapir is found only in another place - in the jungles of South America. It is a living proof that South America and Asia were once joined as a continent before the great geological continental drift begins. The Malayan Tapir is chosen as a the logo of the Malaysian Nature Society.
(The following two-email sequence made me LOL ... they were freakin' hilarious!)
From Northern Africa (2008-02-26):Hello, My name is XXXXXX and am from north Africa. Am using eigenface (pca) method in a face recognition system,and i cant seem to find any source codes or help for that in c++ since am new . I found ur email in the web site, ur a developer in c++ and i was wondering if you can send me the necessary codes or the algorithm pleeeease i really need it as soon as possible am in a hurry. If you do that you l b saving my life!! I really apreciate it if u can help me. looking forward to hearing from u sooner Thanx in advance
(follow-up email, as though he's never contacted me before! this person seems to be semi-randomly spamming people!)
From Northern Africa (2008-03-13):
Hello there!i found ur email in the web site . am doing a project on face recognition using pca with my own data base; and i cant seem to find source code for that in c++ (since ur a c++ programer) , if u could pleeeeeeeeeeease send me coz i cnt find any help,or i l be loosing my diploma this year;and thus may career will b gone, and i dont have any time, this is my last chance............so please help me.waiting for ur reply as soon as possible
From Taiwan (2008-05-30):
Hi Philip,
I stumbled upon your website, end up spending time browsing
it and couldn't quit, amid work. :-) I really like your
website and thought I write to you.
The website layout is excellent and clear, make people at
ease and comfortable. It is an interesting passage from
your first website to the current, offering a glimpse of
boy's development. Some of the nature/landscape photos are
so impressive and I like them very much. I also like the
articles; they are communicating and inviting for thoughts,
even the software ones.
As to the recommended reading list, none of them I read yet.
Just in the spirit of sharing, some books come in mind,
Conversations with God (not religion)
The Color of Water
The Accidental Asian
I am from Taiwan and my son was born here; he is in Junior
year now. I forwarded the link to him, but I think I will
not just buy the book "On the Move" for him yet, otherwise
it might be perceived as overbearing :-)
I am happy for you and your parents.
Wish you the best!
XXXXXX
From Los Angeles, California, USA (2008-08-09):
Hi Philip, I'm XXXXXX, a UCLA undergrad who stumbled upon your website after Googling "On the Move: An Immigrant Child's Global Journey," which is one of the required books in a sociology class about Chinese immigration that I'm taking in the fall. After reading the description about your book, the rest of your site also appealed to me, so curiosity got a hold of me and I browsed around. And what a pleasure! In particular, I enjoyed your photo collection and your writings section. I admire the candidness with which you wrote your articles. Much of what you said resonated with me on a personal level, especially your article about popularity, the Asian parents article, and your tips for life. For instance, I definitely agree with you there on the benefits of getting in-person service; I can attest that it is much more efficient. I look forward to reading your book for my class! Warmly, XXXXXX
From unknown location (2008-08-20):
Just today I was browsing google and somehow ran across your articles on social issues. I must say, everything you said in your articles holds pretty true, especially the one on Asian parents. I just wanted to compliment you on the articles. It seems like you wrote them all with honest experience. Keep it up and let me know if you ever write anything new.
From Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania, USA (2008-08-23):
Hi Philip, I actually found your website as I was looking up information about graduate fellowships (I had just finished reading the essay prompts for the NSF, and since I was at a loss as to how I should get started, my knee jerk reaction was to Google the heck out of 'NSF Graduate Fellowship, Advice" and other variations on that theme). Your advice was/is tremendously helpful and I really appreciate your thoroughness and candor on the finer points of the application process. I also couldn't help but browse through the rest of your website, and was taken in by all the interesting articles (your site is open in like a million tabs in Firefox right now). So aside from wanting to give a shout out to say that I think your webpage is awesome and that I can relate to a lot of the things you mentioned (Asian parents, photography, social -ness), I also wanted to say thanks...for giving me a great way to procrastinate on the fellowship apps - going through your page was definitely time well spent and I look forward to seeing future developments on there Best, XXXXXX
From New Orleans, Louisiana, USA (2008-11-02):
Hi Philip, I am a graduate student at Tulane, and I was googling sites for help with the NSF fellowship and came upon yours. I just wanted to email you that I have not enjoyed reading your helpful hints, which was very helpful, but was fortunate to stumble across your Asian parent's article. You know you should really conduct a study with surveys of Asian students and their feedback of their parents and where they are today. Yours is not the first I have read to state the same sentiments of Asian parents pushing their children to social exclusion but academic prosperity (sort of). If only I was a psychology major =). But anyways, I just wanted to thank you for taking time out to write up advice on obtaining a NSF fellowship, My best, XXXXXX
From Stanford, California, USA (2008-11-12):
hey phil, i'm also a phd at stanford, in the ee department actually. anyway, just thought i'd let you know that two years ago when i was applying to nsf and ndseg fellowships i came across your site and found your fellowship advice very helpful. thanks! i was fortunate to receive the nsf fellowship like you and continue on to phd studies here. anyway, also recently i have found the other advice on your site useful, and even the abercrombie clips amusing. anyway, just thought i'd say thanks for creating a cool website and making your life wisdom open source. XXXXXX
XML Photo Gallery
These emails were written in response to my XML Photo Gallery software project and my photo gallery projects which preceded it.
From unknown location (2003-10-22):
I found your site doing a google search looking for programs/databases that can help me organize my digital photos and provide a dynamic user interface allowing visitors to search photos by various criteria such as date etc. I really like your advance search form. There are lots of programs that allow you post your photos in galleries etc. but I have yet to find one that gives the visitor to the website the ability to select from various filters to view a specific set of images. Your advance search page is great. Like you I got hooked on photography from taking a class in Jr. high and I now do it for a living. I would really like to know how I might borrow or pay you for a template of your database/user interface/advanced search page and/or the components that make it up. I would like to be able to organize my pics with this type of interface adjusted of course to meet my needs.
From Augsburg, Germany (2005-04-19):
Hi Philip! I love your website! I am a German Student majoring in political science and communications. I love the internet so I started Online-Marketing and webdesign (for private use only) and so I am about to finish my first project. I guess I was doing a good job so far ;-) For my next private project I was searching the net to find something like your photo gallery, and I would love to use it! I will download everything and hopefully succeed. As soon as the new project is on, I will set a link to your site.... everybody should set a link to your site ;-) I really love it! Best regards from Augsburg, Germany XXXXXX
From unknown location (2005-07-15):
Hello, Please let me apologize in advance. I am a relative newcomer when it comes to coding in PHP/MySQL/Javascript/HTML etc. etc. I will try and make this as painless as possible. First off let me start by saying your website looks fabulous. In particular your photo gallery is amazing. I was fortunate enough to find it after entering the following search query into google. "picasa scroll javascript" [...]
From unknown location (2005-08-25):
Hi Philip, I saw your XML Photo Gallery project. Simply superb.
From Paris, France (2005-09-02):
Hi Philip, I'm glad I found your xml photo gallery project. I'm going to use it in combination with the picasa plug-in. As an FYI, I'm an English software developer located just ouside of Paris, France. I've been coding for 10 years, and now work 90% of the time in developing web sites in ASP.NET anc C#. I've only done a tiny amount of xslt development. Currently I wish I knew more about regular expressions, XPath and xslt, because I go through a lot of trial and error in using them, but once they work they're awesome. That's why I'm going to try your xml solution! I'll send you more feedback once I've had a chance to try it out. Thanks, XXXXXX
From England (2005-09-21):
Hi, I recently downloaded your XML Photo Gallery software. I'm pleased to report that it worked as advertised and I'm very happy with it. I've done some editing to fix some issues I had with it, as well as adapt it to my preferred way of working. Overall however, a first-rate project! I've already recommended it to one other person interested in the JavaScript part of it, and I'm sure that it'll become more popular with time... Thanks, XXXXXX
From Russia (2005-10-15):
Hello I found your XML gallery very useful. It was just what I needed - a lightweight and easy-to-configure gallery. Thank you very much. Now here's an address [URL excised] if you'd like to see it in action :). The webpage itself is in russian. [...]
From France (maybe?) (2005-10-15):
i think that your XML Photo Gallery is a marvelous tool is it possible to you to send me a zip file of your application thank a lot sorry for my english i'm french see u soon -- XXXXXX
From unknown location (2005-12-05):
Hi, I really enjoyed your XML Photo Gallery program. I was doing a freebie site for a friend, and got another gallery at the last minute, not so fun but I was pleased to find your program. I modified the look a little to blend in with the feel of the original site. [...] I left a link back to your site. So once again props, this is a nicely designed appliction! Regards, XXXXXX
From Colombia (2005-12-16):
Hello, i'm writing from Colombia, Mi name is XXXXXX and I'm learning (in my college), XML, and I'm writing you 'cause I want to use your XML Photo Gallery to learn more of a real implementation of XML, thanks! Cordialmente, XXXXXX
From unknown location (2006-02-05):
Hi Philip, I wanted to share a tweak that I made to your XSLT viewer: [URL excised] It now works natively with Picasa XML. [...] Many thanks. Your viewer is very cool and one of the best "real life" applications of XSLT that I've seen to date. Congrats on some real slick work! XXXXXX
From unknown location (2006-02-22):
Hi Philip, Just wanted to thank you for your xml photo gallery code you shared on your page. I think its some great work showing off javascript, xml and xslt technologies. Check out my page to see your work in use. [URL excised] Many thanks, XXXXXX
From Germany (2006-09-25):
Dear Philip, in the past six weeks I have completely restructured and redesigned the website of the German J/22 Class Association. When looking for a easy-to-setup client-based photo gallery (no database available) I stumbled across your site, respectively software. Unfortunately I can't remember the site containing the link, but 10 minutes after I first read about your concept one of my galleries was already up. Setting up the gallery is incredibly easy (i'm using Mac OS X) but one or the other browser complained about the missing dtd-file. Not being mentioned in the guide though, I simply downloaded it from one of your sample galleries, and it worked. Thank you very much for this excellent piece of software (I especially like the way it can be customized!).
From unknown location (2006-10-01):
ur works are too awesome! :) as i surfed the net for photo gallery with search engine, i found ur site. Its really great!! keep it up.. ^__~ just wanna make new friends in the web :)
From unknown location, USA (2006-10-31):
Phillip, Ok last email.. I found out what I did wrong. I did not download the gallery.dtd file from your site so I have it now and all is working fine now. This is the best gallery I have come across. Thanks, XXXXXX
From unknown location, USA (2006-12-08):
Philip, I just want to say that as a web enthusiast I think your site is awesome. I am slowly trying to teach myself some web stuff so I can put together a family website for my wife and I and I would love to use your code if possible. However, I am having a very rough time trying to understand some of it. I would classify my skills and amateur at best... I come from a graphic design and documentation background. I am trying to develop on Windows XP for IE use... what part of your steps should I use? Any help would be appreciated... and your site very cool. When I get mine up and running, I will send you some links XXXXXX
From New Jersey, USA (2007-02-14):
Philip, Thank you so much for your instructions and code for the XML Photo Gallery. I'm a "first timer" trying to develop a website for my small business and it has been very helpful. [...]
From unknown location (2007-06-06):
Just want to say that your website is simply beautiful. Clever that you are using XSLT! I am also implementing a similar idea (web photo+video gallery) and with a slightly different approach: I will use Javascript to parse the XML document and write the result onto a HTML page using innerHTML. Yes I know it's not a W3C standard, but since they haven't come up with a better idea, innerHTML will do :) By the way I will be using and modifying the BASH script you provided on the site to generate my own XML. I will be modifying it to suit my own condition, as I will need to figure out a way to deal with videos as well, but will release the result under GNU GPLv2. Thanks :) XXXXXX
From unknown location (2007-06-16):
Hello Philip. I stumbled on to you site while searching for ways to add a photo gallery to my October arriving son's website. I was about to buy ThumbGallery when I came across your link. Great site!! With all the different types of info in it, It's definitely more than one would expect to find. [...]
From Sunnyvale, California, USA (2007-12-10):
Hi Philip, A few weeks ago I came across your website from google serach. I was looking for a replacement/modification of Picasa's web album and decided to use your beautiful photo gallery as soon as I saw it. Thank you very much for making your hard work public and thank you for mentioning about directly working with Picasa's xml! My website is primary for my family and friends. A few days ago my mom called me from Taiwan and said that she likes this new photo album! I really appreciate that you make my website possible. XXXXXX (Sunnyvale, CA)
Graduate School and Fellowship Application Tips
These emails were written in response to these two articles: Advice for Graduate School (Ph.D.) Applications and Advice for NSF, NDSEG, and Hertz Fellowship Applications
From Orlando, Florida, USA (2006-10-26):
Hey Philip, I don't suppose you would be willing to review my NSF application and essays for a hopeful fellow? I imagine you get this question quite frequently, but I suppose it's what you would expect after posting your advice on applying for fellowships on the net. Regardless of your answer, thanks for posting the tips. Good stuff! Cheers, XXXXXX
From unknown location, USA (2006-10-31):
Hi, I am XXXXXX, a first year grad student applying for the NSF graduate fellowhsip. I came acrosss your guide to applying for the fellowship, and I must say that it is by far the most useful resource that I have found to help me with my application process. I saw that you had your email address posted on the website and I just wanted to email you and thank you for posting it up for others to benefit from it. It is an invaluable resource and you are doing a great thing by sharing your experience with others. Thanks once again. XXXXXX
From Los Angeles, California, USA (2006-11-02):
Dear Philip, My name is XXXXXX. I recently came across the information you have on your website regarding the Hertz fellowship. I am a grad student at USC studying Electrical Engineering, and I just submitted an application for the Hertz a few days ago. I wanted to thank you for taking the time to post your experiences on the web so that others can learn and benefit. [...] I would really appreciate any further help and advice. Once again, that you for providing the information on the website, it is much appreciated. Sincerely, XXXXXX
From unknown location (2006-11-14):
Hi, Nice intersting site.I am applying for grad school, so was searching for tip on writing my SOP and found your site.Yours is the single most useful advice I have seen till now. keep up the good work. bye, XXXXXX
From unknown location (2006-12-08):
Hi Philip, Just wanted to mention that Google's new Docs & Spreadsheets are a great way to keep track of info for grad school and fellowship information (like you mention for text files, but now you can access them anywhere and never lose them unless google has a catastrophic failure). Your advice is very helpful! Best, XXXXXX
From Malaysia (2006-12-10):
Good day Philip, I was reading your article posted in your website titled "Advice for preparing to apply and actually applying to science Ph.D. programs". It's very informative and useful for people like me, wanting to apply for a doctorate research in US unis. I really hope you'd be able to advise me on some uncertain issues I'm facing currently. [...] I would really appreciate if you could give me your general perception on my ability to pursue a phd in MIT (among other top schools). Can you also tell me if there are anything lacking in me (any qualities or qualification or number of papers in conference....... anything at all). Your advise is highly appreciated. Thanking you in advance and hoping to read your lines soon. Cheers!! -XXXXXX
From unknown location, USA (2007-01-04):
Hello Philip, I read your website regarding graduate fellowships and must say it was extremely helpful. I did read your advice on graduate applications and must say it was spot on except for one thing--contacting professors beforehand. Perhaps it is just my field (I am an oceanography PhD student) but most professors preferred this. I emailed professors then called the ones who emailed me back and expressed an interest in talking one-on-one. Most professors were impressed in my efforts and were more likely to pull my application out of the stack that was piled for review. One professor even went so far as to email me personally when she received my application then told me the next day that I was excepted with a fellowship (one that she told me she would try to push for me to get). Maybe my personal experience is unique but I just thought I would share my experience to add to your wonderful website. Thanks for the advice!! Cheers, XXXXXX
From unknown location, USA (2007-01-07):
Hi Philip, Thanks for your long, informative article on applying to fellowships! It's really helpful, and I certainly wished I had found it on google sooner. Ah well, I don't think I really have a chance at getting NDSEG, but I just put it on my apps to look like I was really trying to get funding instead of just sitting around. Anyway, good luck on your well-funded research! Thanks again, XXXXXX (random person who needed last minute advice on the NDSEG 'summary of goals' and found your site)
From unknown location, USA (2007-03-25):
Hi Philip, I wanted to thank you again for compiling advice on tackling those fellowship apps. I just found out I won the NSF! Best, XXXXXX
From unknown location, USA (2007-03-26):
Hi, Philip. I, too, wanted to thank you for your advice on applying for the NSF, NDSEG, and Hertz fellowships. It definitely helped me to get into the right mood and mindset before I sat down to write my essays.
From unknown location (2007-06-11):
Dear Philip, Thank you for your exemplary advice for those considering phD programs. As others have noted, of all the advice-type musings on the subject of graduate study, your page most clearly and wisely addresses the importance of showing in your application a real interest in and capacity for research. If you have a moment, I would be interested to hear your thoughts on the following topic, which is (go figure) personal rather than hypothetical: [...] Thank you and all best, XXXXXX
From Virginia, USA (2007-06-11):
Dear Philip, First and foremost, thank you for your wonderful website! I used the advice in your columns on graduate school and fellowship applications religiously. Nowhere else on the web did I see such comprehensive and correct information on the general logic behind the application process and such good summaries of the 3 main fellowships. [...] Any advice you have will be helpful. Once again, thanks for your online bible--it helped a ton. Regards, XXXXXX
From San Jose, California, USA (2008-03-31):
Hey Philip Just wanted to let you know that your muse on fellowships helped me win the NDSEG this year. I'd say you were responsible for about 1/3 of the success... the other two being my attendance of grant/fellowship writing workshops and receiving edits from advisors/friends. That's right, you help people earn $90,000. Too bad you don't get any of that, huh? Also, I find your "Asian Parents" article amusing and easily relate-able. Haven't checked out your photos yet, but I'm a Rebel XT fan, my first was the Powershot S30. Anyways, you're an indispensable resource. Keep it up wise guy XXXXXX
From Berkeley, California, USA (2008-04-02):
Hi Phillip, So I googled fellowships before applying and your name popped up. The advice was extremely helpful in getting me the NSF. I also got alternate in the NDSEG and finalist in the Hertz. You are awesome for taking the time to share a small taste of your success. Best, XXXXXX P.S. Your Turok slang cracks me up.
From Florida, USA (2008-04-17):
Philip, Just wanted to say thanks for your article on graduate science fellowships. It was very helpful and good to read from a person who had already gone through the process. Anyways, I, like you, received a first-round Hertz interview and it was crazy. I am happy to have received an NSF fellowship and will be joining you at Stanford in the fall. XXXXXX
From Toronto, Canada (2008-09-20):
Hi Philip, I was given your article "Advice for preparing to apply and actually applying to science Ph.D. programs" by a grad student at MIT and I found it very insightful. I'll definitely be using your advice. Thank you for writing it. I am going to be applying to Graduate School at Stanford this year (either CS or EE) and I had a few questions. Would you mind answering them? Thanks! XXXXXX
From unknown location (2008-09-22):
Hi Philip, I came across your website by way of the helpful hints for grad student fellowships. I just wanted to say thanks for this bit of advice - every little bit helps! Also, i do enjoy the rest of your website. XXXXXX
From Cambridge, Massachusetts, USA (2008-10-29):
Hi Philip, I stumbled across your website when searching for advice on applying to external fellowships. Your website is really wonderful and has helped me a lot as I think through my application essays. Thank you! Being a procrastinator by nature, I decided that browsing your website would be a better use of my time than actually writing these essays. I noticed that you have a similar experience as I did in moving to different continents and countries as a child. [...] Thank you again for your help! Best, XXXXXX
From North Carolina, USA (2009-03-31):
Hi Philip! I'm an undergrad at Duke in Physics/EE right now, probably going to Caltech for biochem/biophys next year. Your advice on your website about applying to science fellowships has been absolutely invaluable to me and was a tremendously important guide through the graduate fellowship waters. I just found out I won an NDSEG. I feel that I owe the honor in part to your generosity with your knowledge about the process and wanted to thank you. So, thank you very very much! Best, XXXXXX
On Popularity
These emails were written in response to this article: On Popularity
From Argentina (2006-10-12):
Hi, I got to your site when googling "old websites". You see, I am young enough to remember my early tinkering with the web, but too young to remember the really prehistoric internet. Still, I enjoy looking at how websites changed and stuff like guestbooks, gifs and general layout developed. I read your popularity article and I loved it. Every sentence popped up a memory, even though I'm in 10th grade (I'm not sure that's the right way to say it, but I don't understand the american year thingy) so I'm still working on popularity :P The thing is, here in Argentina the popular thing is definitely there, but it is less important and less conscious: the first time I actively talked about the "cool kids" was in a roleplaying session this year. Popular kids don't mock others, and there is a kind of active effort to integrate everyone, make sure you don't just stick to your 3-person group. I had been thinking about the newcomer loophole while reading the middle of your article, and was pleased to see it in the end. Although I would be scared of losing my friends, now I understand a new school might give me interesting possibilities. Great site, XXXXXX
From Houston, Texas, USA (2006-11-08):
Hi In regards to your popularity article, I thought you might want to read Paul Graham's essay if you haven't already at http://www.paulgraham.com/nerds.html From your writing it seems like you haven't, and it is a great read. Paul's and your essays take very different approaches, so it seems hard to compare the two directly. Interesting nonetheless. See ya, XXXXXX Rice University '09
From unknown location (2007-03-19):
[...] I was actually searching for fashion tips when I stumbled upon your thoughts on popularity. An insightful piece, and very true in my personal experience. [...] Your brief section about friends in grade school really hit home. I only have one major friend from elementary school that I've kept to the present day. In fifth grade, I was friends with people who are now, respectively: a drama geek, a druggie, a skater, and a popular kid. None of them do so much as say hello to me in the hallway now, although I can hardly blame them. A thought: is popularity genetic? [...] Are we doomed from birth if born into a family of geeks (or perhaps popular people, if you'd like to think of it that way)? Grateful for your insight, XXXXXXFrom China (2007-06-29):
Hello Philip, I read your article of teenage popularity and dork culture this morning and enjoyed your insights. I also had a little to add to your theory of finality "once once a dork, always a dork". I'm an American designer living in China working in a factory. I am staffed with approximately 12 other American designers within the the decor industry. I am [...] (married with kids), and even after all these years, still feel the outsider. Though your observations of adolescence angst are definitely at their worst when one is young, the patterns of social popularity can and do play themselves out much the same way later in life. I mention what I do for a living to bring up a point: I am in a job I'm well suited for and in a demographic where I should be high on the caste system but for reasons of my personality, keep myself apart from the mainstream. I am also the only straight guy in a company of gay men and older women. Though out of preference, I would prefer to work around other straight men, it would not ultimately make much difference of how I would interact with the people or make me any popular as a person. My situation is a little unique, an straight American living in remote gay China, a little of the beaten track. Dorks (we) are a fickle bunch that often are overlooked easy and even more, misunderstood, so we tend to gravitate to other that likeminded, intellectual and non-threatening. In my case, I'm very fickle of who I trust in my circle, a trait I developed to protect myself from back in my school days. This disables me to raising the ranks in my work, thought not on how well I fundamentally do my job. An observation I have made on popularity in adulthood and the workplace is that those least popular on the productivity spectrum are usually the most important and productive. As those in the "least productive" are usually the most liked. Thus a certain President. Your argument about cloths don't necessarily make a man is true. An example, I am considered a good looking, fit, 6'4 who did end up marrying a model. Because of my looks, attracting people to me has ever been a problem. The flip side, is I'm much of the same isolated boy I was. I am not comfortable around most people, and tend to become disinterested in what I consider "trite" conversation. I suppose I'm a dork with a "snob" complex. The point to this is, we are who we are, and it is possible to understand it and accept it. I do accept your epilogue statement about getting involved in social activities, especially if those activities pair you up with people of the same interests. This will help one develop social skills later in life and help develop a sense of purpose. Be yourself, even if that doesn't attract the people around you that you want. It may isolate you, but that's ok. Advise I would have wanted when I was young would simply be: try not to take yourself too seriously and don't be so hard on yourself. Regards, XXXXXXFrom unknown location (2007-10-18):
Hello Philip- Your article on popularity is quite unique. For a tech-type you have great insight into social issues, and have obviously given a lot of thought to what you have written, which rings very true. I think you are right about the lack of upward mobility and the newcomer loophole. But I would have one comment to make on calling those kids everyone looks up to "popular." I have renamed them the "fast kids," because they are the ones doing everything first. And you are right that it starts in 6th grade if a middle school, and 7th if it is a junior high setting. Many kids in 6th grade are still just that, kids. While others have made the transition to "teenager," meaning being driven toward the opposite sex by hormones! This happens at different times for all of us, but the ones who get a head start in middle school/junior high will always be the standard-setters. The slower kids may turn out to be better looking and better all around, but will have to wait until A) a new school where noone knows them or B) graduation, to be rise to their deserved position socially. The died-in-the wool jocks also make up a large portion of the "fast crowd," because I think it has to be hormones that makes those driven athletes break out from the crowd. These aggressive, driven types are always looking for the "next thing," and seem to form their own society with its own caste system. You can be on the team, but that does not make you "one of them." But I don't see these kids as "popular," because they look through average kids as if they are not even there, are not always nice, and make the rest of the kids feel like crapby comparison because they are NOT doing all of those things yet. They are popular amongst each other, but the rest, and I mean the MAJORITY of the kids are left to fend for themselves and end up doing a pretty good job of it. You take someone who is chugging along, doing the right thing, growing up in fits and starts, making friends, not perfect at anything, but doesn't make anyone feel bad, medium looks, not outrageous behavior, and at the end of the day this is a popular kid, meaning liked by EVERYONE. Many of those fast kids are truly hated, and I feel that the average kid who can relate to the goth, the thespian, the dork and the mediocre athlete will do better overall in life, because being able to relate to all types of people is important in just about any career. Not to mention the fact that the fast kids get into all kinds of unhealthy stuff looking for the next thrill. Yes, you are right that there is the rare "have it all" kid who moves with the fast crowd, is nice to everyone, great looking, successful...but most are not, and stay within their own crowd for fear of ridicule. Believe me, nothing has changed in the 10 years since you were in middle/high school. Things were like this in the 70's when I was going through it and right now as my 11-year-old 6th grade daughter (with super-model looks, but who still plays with dolls, so she is definitely not in the fast crowd) and 9th grade son (who still hasn't put away the Legos) can attest to. As a parent I do not want them in the fast crowd, but I want them to have great self-esteem and your point about accepting your position is very wise. A few good friends can carry you far in life. 7th grade was the first year of junior high for me and I met a life-long friend playing field hockey in gym class, because it was obvious we were both going to stay as far away from the ball as possible! Neither of us even dated in high school but we were well liked, nice looking girls who were involved in activities, had friends and went off to good colleges. Our days for romance came once we were out of the "the system" in which we were "not date-able," but in the meantime during high school we didn't piss anyone off, and buoyed by friends and activites had enough self esteem to run for and win treasurer (her) and secretary (me) of our senior class. We are both married now, and I have to say, when we went back to our most recent reunion we looked at our tall handsome husbands and thought we had done far better than most in that department, despite a late start out of the gate!
From unknown location (2007-11-06):
Hey! I landed on your website whilst googling on the internet and came across your article on popularity,and just had to say congradulations for taking the time and energy to write something so damn real and intresting,and most importantly of all TRUE. After i read the article i sent it to all my friends and just like anyone who reads the article,we can all relate to it in someway or another, I think its great how you show that even as young adults we form social groups and judge one another on things such as appearance and the latest fashion trends, Your article just relates heavily to my own personal journey through secondry school(high school) as i at first wasnt luckily enough at first to be blessed with good looks between the ages on 11-13 as when you so greatly described is generally the age when high school popularity really starts to kick in,i was just a real skinny arkward kid at school who was very reserved and really shy,infact the only reason i became semi popular with the guys at my school was because i happend to be good at sports,predominantly the main one being soccer,and i had this weird sense of humour that the real popular kids found highly amusing,but when it came to girls i just wasnt in the running at all,and i never could figure it out why they didnt like me,and would time and time again go for the loser badboy idiot types, Anyway im what your article describes as a late bloomer and suddenly out of absoloutely nowhere girls started liking me and actually now knew i existed,i also started becomeing more popular with all the guys two, they all suddenly started showing more intrest in what i did out of school and what my hobbies were,and the only sole reason for this what i can think of anyway was because now i was all of a sudden "good looking" id just about finished puberty,i looked more mature,and worked out a lot. people continued to like me and show intrest in me all the way through college and beyond,and most of them dont even realize that back in school i was just a skinny nerdy kid. Anyway i guess the moral of my story is that its crazy that people can suddenly become popular more or less overnight just based on their physical attributes,i think this may have something to do with the halo-effect where people attach certain characteristics to people based on how they look.and having being on both sides of the fence and being treated accordingly because of how i looked it just makes me sick on how people can do this and feel ok about it,one thing it has taught me is that just because someone looks a certain way u should never judge them,and its whats inside that counts best... Sorry about the rant lol,just thought your article was a mini genious piece of writing,and shall be reading more of your articles,and hope for more in the future... I hope to hear back from you sir.... Thanks for your time x
From unknown location (2008-02-13):
Philip, Enjoyed your thoughtful reflection and analysis. But I have a simpler hypothesis: serotonin. There are no popular introverts that I recall. Nor angry or depressed ones. Serotonin levels influence that to a great degree. Thoughts? XXXXXX
From unknown location (2008-08-21):
I thought your article on popularity was awesome and very well and clearly thought out. I enjoyed reading it as well as your other articles on friendship. I am a secondary school student and i am going through the motions of secondary social life and although i don't think i am exactly a nerd, but i'm pretty down low on the social hierarchy ladder. I am actually experiencing something almost similar to the whole popular and unpopular thing, but in a slightly different way. See, in my school, or at least, in my class, different people are treated differently according to popularity. The loud, bold, brash ones are the popular people, while the quiet ones who don't speak up much, or stick to their little group, or who aren't as loud, funny and homourous are the ignored, unpopular people. As my classmate nicely puts it, you have to have personality to survive in class. THese popular people are not based on their looks or athletic ability. Its their personality. The popular ones are seen and heard, and the unpopular ones are just not heard at all. Teachers complain that the class is too noisy, too loud and that not all of us take our studies seriously. But when push comes to shove, they like the loud ones best. For their outspoken-ness, their wit and personality. Or worse, their goofs and idiotic acts that are endearing. Why is that? And also, i find that people react differently to different people. If a certain person does something silly and says something really lame, the whole class erupts into laughter when in fact, it really is all it is. Lame. They laugh so hard at something that few of us find not funny at all. However, if a less than popular student tries the exact same thing, does a lame joke or lame act, it would not be as well received. It seems that they have this mindset already, that when it is someone they're close with or someone they think is funny, they react a certain way, and vice versa. I think its all about mindsets and perspectives. Another matter i find really annoying is this:how some people think that they are exercising their right to voice out and give opinions and talk about how they really feel, when all they are actually doing is reacting very childishly and think that they are far superior to the teachers and other classmates. In a simple matter of the teacher being preoccupied with other students, some think that the teacher is purposefully ignoring their call for assistance in school work. And then, they proceed to talk very loudly and point out to the whole class that the teacher is doing it on purpose. In another case, some were making too much noise in the one hour that we had before an assessment was due to start. When the teacher told the class to tone it down or get out, some reacted by telling the teacher to shut up. I think that it shows a lack of proper upbringing by their parents.I know some outspoken individuals, but this one in particular had to respect at all for the teacher by informing the teacher to shut up. although some of the others didn't like the teacher, they knew where the line was and when is it too much to speak their minds. I think that it is both the parents' and the child's fault that the child was brought up to believe that they could say whatever they want whenever they want. Don't get me wrong, i'm all for freedom of speech, but when moral boundaries are overstepped, it is no longer freedom of speech, it is merely bad behaviour. The sad thing is, it is people like this who are popular. If it is possible, i would greatly appreciate feedback. I am also actually doing a bit of research into how people think and act and why do they act the way they do.Something of the sort. So i would love to hear any insight that you may have on topics like this. Thank you!
From San Juan Capistrano, California, USA (2008-11-19):
Phillip, Thank you so much for taking the time to reply and send your thoughts and the links. I have forwarded your email on to my student. I also enjoyed reading the article of yours that she found online. From my own experience as a student and my experience teaching middle school students, I found your observations about popularity to be interesting and accurate. Thanks again, XXXXXX
Attention: Overbearing Asian Parents
Since I've received quite a bit of email regarding Attention: Overbearing Asian Parents, I decided to start a dedicated discussion forum, seeded with these emails (posted as username anonymous_email). It's very easy to participate in the dialogue; you can post anonymously.
In addition, see my Responses to Attention: Overbearing Asian Parents article for a sampling of these emails with my added commentary.
Radness and Lameness
These emails were written in response to this article: Radness and Lameness
From Stanford, California, USA (2007-12-27):
i forgot what i wanted to say, but i think it was along of the lines of: you are encouraging people to resign themselves to their lameness. Sounds somewhat defeatist. I would argue that challenging one's lameness and acting contrary to the lameness others view you as having can have positive repercussions. In other words, if someone thinks you are lame, yet you don't act like you don't believe you are lame, this can often make them realize that hey, maybe this guy isnt so lame after all and theres something going for him that i dont know about. Of course, if not done right this can backfire in the manner that you describe in your article, though that is not inevitable by any means.
From unknown location (2008-10-20):
Hello, I read your "Radness and Lameness" article and this is my response. Yesterday, my friend and I were singing "You're really lame!" in tune with a song playing on my car stereo. I laughed until I cried. Then we added "I am a dork!" alternating with "You're really lame!" and it was even funnier. Why? Because making fun of oneself is just as fun as making fun of others. Sadly, your article missed this point, regarding which, I have several observations. "In sum, the relative radness levels of two people on each other's radness/lameness scales determines the nature of their interactions." In reality the nature of two people's interactions depends on: 1. The reason two individuals interact. 2. The manner in which the two individuals interact. 3. How each individual responds to the other. None of these has anything to do with "radness" or "lameness." "Always try very, very hard to determine exactly where you stand on other people's radness/lameness scales, and set your expectations and demeanor accordingly." I used to do this and it made me crazy and unhappy. Today I rarely give a fig for what others think of me. Therefore I attract fewer negative people and more positive ones. I also have much more fun. In conclusion, you're really lame, but I am a dork. Love, XXXXXX
Random Browser
These emails were written in response to my Random Browser software project:
From Edinburgh, Scotland (2007-05-07):
Hi Philip, I am doing a review of photoware and browsing apps and stumbled upon your work and am really impressed! I'm the Research Fellow at Napier University on the COMPANIONS project which is a 4 year European project looking at the notion of intelligent, persistent, character based interfaces [...]From unknown location (2007-10-09):
Hello Philip, I came across your site in search for a photo gallery (and might come back to the XML Photo Gallery after I try each and every one available :-S) and was astonished when I found your Random Browser: 1) browsing my photos in an intelligent way to train my rusty brain 2) python 3) ergo: MUST have *pretty pretty please* :-D What I can offer you in return would be to try to test it on Debian 4.0 and OSX 10.3.9 (and of course lament all it's shortcomings (well - if I would manage to find any ;-))) thanks! XXXXXX
Types of Friends
These emails were written in response to this article: Types of Friends
From unknown location (2007-12-01):
Hi there, Just wanna drop you a line to tell you that i do enjoy reading your post and i have bookmark your site as one of my favourites. Thanks for your nice writings. Really do enjoy reading it. [...] I was 'googling' for types of friends and found your site. I love reading your social section, maybe cuz i am a female. You know, the women kinda sentimental feelings..... just love reading about your opinion. Hope my 2-cents would be a good feedback to you. [...] Oh yeah, btw, would it okay for me to post your 'types of friends article' on my blog? Found it to be very interesting and was hoping to share it out :). Thanks again. Regards, XXXXXX
From New York, NY, USA (2008-10-29):
I feel like we are type-3 to type-4 friends, so I will keep this email brief. ;) I think reading those essays are interesting for me to reflect upon my current circle of friends and to see how I can cultivate some more type-1 and type-2 friends. There is also this interesting effect of time not quite addressed in your type system - I am very good friends with some people from college, so I can talk to them for a while, but they've moved from type-1 to type-2, I suspect, due to a lack of more recent shared experiences. [...] The only thing I wanted to say about the friend type system is that you may have a set of friends who are very close, but in my experience, the time-decay factor eventually catches up with you if you don't have quite enough shared experiences, so even if you have very good friends, a gap of a year, or two, or three, will eventually cause you to drift apart. I suppose the lesson I've drawn from that is to make sure to take the time to have some shared experiences with those friends and don't let that time gap grow too much.
From unknown location (2009-06-01):
I was reading your article http://www.stanford.edu/~pgbovine/types-of-friends.htm and I totally agree. I'm going to create Facebook friend groups based on Friend Types. Type 1 will get full profile access and Type 5 will be very limited. I can't decide if I should treat my family as Type 0 or Type 6? Thanks for the good read! XXXXXX
Types of Facebook Photos
These emails were written in response to this article: Types of Facebook Photos
From unknown location (2007-05-16):
Funny shit . Laughed out loud. Hard. I've noticed a lot of "I used to look good" profile photos also. These are mostly from people 25+ posting some picture of them self at 18-22 looking really tanned, fresh etc. When you meet them irl it looks like they aged 7 years, gained 20 pounds and got pale over night. XXXXXX
Computer Science in Modern Everyday Life
These emails were written in response to this article: Computer Science in Modern Everyday Life
From Brazil (2007-06-22):
Greetings! My name is XXXXXX and I'm from Brazil. Your site was one of the many thousands of results I got when I searched "Computer Science" and "teenagers." I was really interested in your article "Computer Science in Modern Everyday Life," because I myself am wondering if Computer Science would be the right major for me. I applied to a University, wanting to do Business or Communication, but I got accepted into Computer Science. And somehow I just don't know what to do. I know I like Business, especially Administration or Management, but then again, I don't know if I want to miss out on this new opportunity. I'm fairly good at Math and such but nothing extra-ordinary. My guidance counselor says that maybe I won't be able to cope with the Math and the coursework, but it's worth a try. I'm just desperately trying to find out what to do. After I read your article, it just click that those are questions that I'm constantly asking myself. I don't know. I don't even know where I'm trying to get here. Thanks for letting me vent. XXXXXX
Unison
These emails were written in response to these articles: Unison File Synchronizer: Liberation through Data Replication and Setting up Unison for your mom
From England (2007-07-26):
Dear Philip, I read your deliberations about the advantages of 'Unison' with great interest, have been using it for a while now (like it a lot) and have found your setup-for-ya-mom very useful. Thank you very much. [...] Once again, thank you for your efforts! Yours, XXXXXX
From Germany (2007-07-28):
Dear Philip, I read your deliberations about the advantages of 'Unison' with great interest, have been using it for a while now (like it a lot) and have found your setup-for-ya-mom very useful. Thank you very much. [...] Once again, thank you for your efforts! Yours, XXXXXX
From Tokyo, Japan (2008-12-07):
Philip Guo, I'm just a user of Unison for file synchronizing that is very thankful for you write-ups. I rarely write thank you messages to people on the internet but this time I felt compelled to. I spent several hours researching Unison and how it could help me sync and backup my files on my network (running 3~4 computers). I got frustrated when after several hours I couldn't get through the geek speak. But then I ran across your "Unison File Synchronizer: Liberation through Data Replication" article. And finally it all made sense!! Thanks for your excellent work. I then started reading up lots of stuff on your site. You write well and in a way that's easy to understand and gets to the point. Thanks, XXXXXX
Introductory Computer Programming Education
These emails were written in response to this article: Introductory Computer Programming Education
From unknown location (2007-08-12):
Dear Philip,
Hello Mr. Bovine, my name is XXXXXX, I stumbled across your
fantastic piece {../pgbovine/www/prog-curriculum.htmon} and
I just wanted to thank you for the article for it helps me
to look at a realistic approach to learning how to develop
as a programmer.
[...]
A few years ago, a family friend gave me books on Java from
Sun...but having no programming experience I was quite
literally LOST. There were so many fundamental concepts
that I was unfamiliar with, that I lost my perspective and
soon gave up. I now have the new version of Eclipse Europa,
(Java 2EE with WTP) and a couple of plug-ins (CFEclipse,
JSEclipse), but I feel some what like I did before. LOST
again....How do I build a solid programming education,
without college or on the job training?
<question> Seeing that I am learning on my own, without
formal guidance or training, could you suggest a good list
of resources for me to learn how to develop as a programmer?
</question>
Thanks in advance.....
XXXXXX
From unknown location (2007-10-29):
Philip, I enjoyed your observations on programming, especially for beginners. Beginners want to learn programming to start achieving some results, not slaving away in monkish isolation awaiting some eventual payback. Python is a much better way to start than C. The power of bash/ksh and the standard Unix toolkit is vastly underappreciated by the point-and-clickers. Awk, sort, sed, grep, xargs, find, and their cousins can solve the bulk of the little problems that pop up with trivial amounts of code. When you're done, call those 5-6 bash scripts you created in a 30 line Tcl/Tk program and you've created a quick and dirty GUI app with well tested guts in an afternoon. A few years ago I performed a data analysis task on about 150 sets of data. They were analyzed by a collection of octave and awk scripts feeding gnuplot to generate the graphics. All the sets were organized in a tree corresponding to sections with small files of descriptive text. Make was used to build all the tables and figures recursively and M4 scripts built the DocBook report - in PDF and HTML. When 100 data sets were added they got placed in the tree and I had a new report in about an hour after typing "make report.pdf". Good luck doing that with VBasic and MS Office!! Regards, XXXXXX
From unknown location (2008-02-15):
Dear Sir, Wow! I'm impressed! What a wonderful and well-written article! I am truly a beginner at this computer thing. I grew up in a time when there was no such thing as computers, and have wanted to learn more about computers and programming, but have been very frustrated in my quest to find a beginner's course that will actually help me learn what I need/want to learn. I've found that course descriptions and/or instructors either speak way over my head - or simplify things to the point I feel like I'm in Kindergarten again! What I really want to learn more about are the basics, such as html and javascript - not mathematical and/or "toy" functions, but to be frank, it is difficult to find a course well-suited to the beginner. Your article really speaks to those of us who had neither the priveledge, nor opportunity, to grow up in a computer age. In words from my generation, you hit the nail on the head with your aritcle! Ironically, I've found that I'm having much greater success with learning the "real" skills - the skills I want/need to learn, simply by doing web searches, and gratefully purusing the wonderful, FREE websites out there, such as html4newbies and javascriptsource, that guide beginners through the basics! Anyway, enough of my rambling. I just wanted to compliment you on the article you wrote. Sincerely, XXXXXX
From unknown location (2008-02-26):
Dear Mr. Philip Guo, After reading the following page I want to ask some questions from you HYPERLINK "http://www.stanford.edu/~pgbovine/prog-curriculum.htm" I am going to teach computer programming next term for electrical engineering bachelor students (novice at programming). Have you any advice for teaching low level hardware manipulation like working with computer COM and LPT ports during this course? Specially that the attendees are electrical engineering students? Do you think that they need OO concepts!? With these consideration is C++ better than Java or C# because it is somehow lower level than these two. And the last question, do you have any comments for C#? Thank you in advance, XXXXXX
Some Tips for Life
These emails were written in response to this article: Some Tips for Life
From unknown location (2008-08-31):
I find the website very informative, especially the life wisdom in the page "Some Tips for Life". It's unfortunate that in our age depth is valued over breadth, knowledge over wisdom, and specialization over generalization. This attitude is reflected in our educational system where, for most colleges, the goal is not to provide one the tools to search for meaning in life, rather to prepare one to go into the market place or do research. The Art of Worldly Wisdom by Baltasar Gracian, awesome book. Thank You
Recommended Reading
These emails were written in response to this article: Recommended Reading
From Tallinn, Estonia (2007-10-09):
Hon. Philip Guo I was astonished by your homepage while surfing the net and was hoping that you, as a person with broad set of knowledges could help me. I am a second year undergraduate student in Tallinn University (department of physics), also the secretary of natural sciences. I am most unsatisfied by the situation of our physics department library. Most of the Estonian versions of the recommended reading are from 70's, and all other in Russian, and most of the youth are not competent to work with this material. I have started to make a list of all the books we should order. Mostly I am interested in physics for undergraduate students, but also physics specially statistical physics applied to natural sciences and sociology also maybe you could recommend some other reading for broadening natural scientists conceptions. Best regards, XXXXXX
On Grades
These emails were written in response to this article: On Grades
From unknown location, USA (2008-11-04):
I thoroughly enjoyed reading your article on grades and appreciate your viewpoints. I am a middle school teacher of math and science at a private school. Several years ago, we gave effort grades to our students. These grades are mostly subjective, and as a math and science teacher, I object to effort grades. Most of the teachers at our school agreed and this grading system was tossed out. Now our "new" administrators are considering reinstating effort grades at all levels, grades Pre-K through grade 12. At this time, most teachers incorporate "effort" into our grading system by requiring students to follow accepted formats for completing assignments and completing the assignments by a "due date". For example, if an assignment is required to be typed, double spaced, and due by Friday, points are lost for not adhering to these requirements. Some of our administrators believe that only the content should be graded for an academic grade, and the above criteria should receive a separate effort grade. I'm interested in knowing your thoughts, and if you can direct me to any research on the value of effort grades. Thank you for your time and attention to my querie. Sincerely, XXXXXX
Last modified: 2009-06-05
