FRENCH 189Q, Spring 2000-2001

SOPHOMORE SEMINAR

 

ROMANCE: TEXTS AND MOVIES

 

HAND OUT 21

 

TRAGIC ENDINGS

(MARIE'S EQUITAN, AND LOVE STORY)

 

INTRO:

A. LOVE AND DEATH

We've seen the connection beteen love (eros) and death (thanatos) in a number of documents, including the medieval myth of Tristan and Ysolde, and the movies The English Patient, Jules & Jim, and Love Story.

 

¥What's "romantic" in this connection between love and death? What's its significance in the Tristan myth according to the 12th-century poet, Thomas?

 

¥To what extent can we say that The English Patient is a modern reinscription of the medieval myth? Or, is Love Story closer to the Tristan legend?

 

B. COURTLY ROMANCE ... IS NO ROMANCE

The workings of mimetic desire; the workings of mimetic rivalry; the "beloved" as object of desire; as "prize"; as "love interest"; as pre-text.

 

 

************ DISCUSSION ************

I. LOVE STORY AND THE EMERGENCE OF LOVE

At issue: What distinguishes Oliver and Jenny from the lovers of the courtly tradition?

a) Away from the Narcissus paradigm (Oliver and Jenny as distinct entities);

b) Away from the Pygmalion paradigm (Oliver and Jenny as autonomous entities);

c) Being in love, versus falling in love:

--falling in love at-first-sight (Yvain);

--falling in love at-hearsay (Equitan).

 

II. THE BLOSSOMING OF LOVE

At issue: What is unusual in the affective ties that unite Oliver and Jenny?

a) Away from hierarchical distance (see Equitan: not an emblem of equity but of aggression of horse-culture, "equus");

b) Away from the workings of mimetic desire (see Equitan's desire to possess his seneschal's wife: motivated by the impulses of envy and rivalry);

c) Connection betwen passion, intimacy, and commitment.

 

III. THE FATE OF LOVE

At issue: which obstacles reaffirm, and which endanger, the protagonists' love story?

Away from the triangle as a structure of rivalry; away from lethal resolutions (from 3 to 2 or 1); love in death (perennity of the loving duo).

 

IV. LOVE STORY AS CONVENTIONAL ROMANCE

At issue: to what extent is Love Story a "fairy tale"?

The colorization of love; the clichés; ars moriendi (the "art of dying").

TRANSITION towards next week's topic: self-sacrifice and ars vivendi (the "art of living").