Transcontinental Railroad
On May 10, 1869, the Central Pacific Railway met the Union Pacific Railway in Promontory Point, Utah, marking the completion of the transcontinental railroad. Congress had passed the Pacific Railway Act of 1863, which financed the construction of the railroad through loans and land grants. The lands surrounding the railroads were supposed to be sold for revenue to pay back the loans, (though this was ultimately not done). The actual construction of the railroad could not have been completed without the labor of hundreds of thousands of workers, many of them immigrants. Chinese immigrants played a critical role in building the Central Pacific Railway. The first passage was written by a San Franciscan in the late nineteenth century. The second passage is by a historian who tells a different story about the railroads.
WHAT CALIFORNIA RAILROADS HAVE DONE by David L. Phillips
Building the transcontinental railroad, 1868.
Source: California State Railroad Museum Library. http://usinfo.state.gov
Source: Library of Congress, American Memory. http://memory.loc.gov/ammem/cbhtml/cbmissio.html
Historian
In a relatively short period, the railroads created the skeletal structure of the western transportation system. . . . [However, there was] another aspect of the railroad network that soon became all too apparent: much of the track could not dependably carry freight. Despite all the effort that went into them, these lines were poorly constructed. Railroad technology remained primitive. Iron rails rusted quickly, and untreated wooden ties rotted between them. Engineers made curves too sharp, and workers laid ballast improperly so that the roadbeds collapsed. On the whole, the western railroads may have been no more shoddily built than those in the East, but nonetheless, most of them demanded almost immediate rebuilding. . . . By the time the Union Pacific made its juncture with the Central Pacific, the line already needed nearly 7 million dollars' worth of repairs, and the worst sections of its tracks could barely support a locomotive.
The collapse of the railroads in the larger wreckage [of the panic] of 1873 fueled what would become the chronic resentment of westerners toward both the railroads and their eastern and foreign bondholders. Towns, counties, and states that had bought bonds to finance the railroads found their bonds worthless and the tax dollars used to pay for them wasted. . . . With the railroads bankrupt, westerners hostile, and eastern and European investors wary, railroad building slowed drastically following the panic of 1873.
Source: White, Richard. “It’s Your Misfortune and None of My Own.” University of Oklahoma Press, 1991. 251-252.
Questions:
1. What factors contributed to the completion of the transcontinental railroad?
2. According to the first passage, what segments of the population will benefit from the completion of the transcontinental railroad(e.g., farmers, merchants, landowners, etc.)?
3. According to the second passage, why were westerners resentful of the railroads?
4. Why might the two authors have such different perspectives on the success of the railroads?
