Validation of Computer Simulations of Protein Folding
Validation
of Computer Simulations | Computational
Methods
Protein folding takes place in millionth of a second (10-6
seconds or microseconds). As one imagine to get experimental data to validate
computational methods in protein folding is not an easy task. Folded states
of proteins can be routinely validated by x-ray
diffraction or Nuclear
Magnetic Resonance (NMR) data. Protein Data
Bank (PDB) files are usually derived from x-ray diffraction and
NMR analysis.
Fortunately experimental methods exist to validate the results of computer
simulations of protein folding. Some amino acids fluoresce.
Because it is a non-invasive technique, fluorescence does not interfere
with a sample. The excitation light levels required to generate a fluorescence
signal are low, reducing the effects of photo-bleaching, and living tissue
can be investigated with no adverse effects on its natural physiological
behavior. Of the 20 amino acids usually found in proteins, the aromatic
phenylalanine, tyrosine and tryptophane are the only ones of sufficient
fluorescence intensity to be measured directly in solution. The fluorescence
of proteins due to these residues is a highly specific and sensitive tool
for studying structure and conformation.
The fluorescence of the aromatic residues varies in somewhat unpredictable
manner in various proteins. Comparing to the unfolded state, the quantum
yield may be either increased or decreased by the folding. Accordingly,
a folded protein can have either greater or less fluorescence than the
unfolded form. The intensity of fluorescence is not very informative in
itself. The magnitude of intensity, however, can serve as a probe of perturbations
of the folded state. The wavelength of the emitted light is a better indication
of the environment of the fluorophore. Tryptophan residues that are exposed
to water, have maximal fluorescence at a wavelength of about 340-350 nm,
whereas totally buried residues fluoresce at about 330 nm.
Proteins in an aqueous solution are placed in the "sample cell".
The proteins are unfolded by cooling to low temperatures (cold denaturation).
Folding is then reinitiated by laser-jumping the temperature of the aqueous
protein sample in a few nanoseconds. The temperature-jump 'instantaneously'
changes the aqueous environment from one that favors the unfolded protein
conformation to one favoring the folded conformation, thus initiating
refolding. Alternatively, temperature-jump initiated unfolding may also
be studied. A UV beam probes the protein generating fluorescence. A photomultiplier
tube detects the light generated by fluorescence and the intensity of
the light depends on the folding state of the protein. As the protein
folds, the hydrophobic tryptophane amino acids gets buried inside the
protein structure and their fluorescence gets masked. Protein folding
can be monitored in real time by collecting laser induced fluorescence
from the protein's tryptophan residues once every 14 ns. From intensity
and wavelength studies the folding rate of proteins can be measured experimentally.

Key:
TEC - thermoelectric cooling unit is used to supercool aqueous samples.
IN - insulation surrounds aluminum sample housing.
IR - infrared laser pulses for sample heating (1541 nm) Counter propagating
pulses heat the sample uniformly.
TH - thermistor temperature probes
DL - chopped CW diode laser beam - "optical thermometer"
UV - 280nm ultraviolet laser beam from frequency-tripled, mode-locked
Ti:Sapphire laser probes protein structural changes.
PMT - photomultiplier tube detects fluorescence of sample.
Image is courtesy of Gruebele Group: http://www.scs.uiuc.edu/mgweb/protein_folding_research.shtml
From studies like the ones described above, folding rate of proteins
can be measured experimentally. As the graph below indicates there is
a strong correlation between prediction by computer simulations of protein
foldings generated by folding@home
and experimental results.

Author: Tug Sezen
References:
- We thank Gruebele Group: (http://www.scs.uiuc.edu/mgweb/protein_folding_research.shtml)
for the diagram of the experimental setting and the description of experimental
methods.
- Vijay. S. Pande,
Ian Baker, Jarrod Chapman, Sidney Elmer, Siraj Khaliq, Stefan Larson,
Young Min Rhee, Michael Shirts, Christopher Snow, Eric J. Sorin and
Bojan Zagrovic To appear in the Peter Kollman Memorial Issue, Biopolymers
(2002)
- Ballew, Sabelko, Gruebele (1996), Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. USA Vol 93,
pp. 5759-5764
|