The Ben Linder Mystery is an
activity for students to use Internet resources to learn about the
politics and history behind the death of Ben Linder. As an American
who was represented in Nicaraguan murals including the one above his
life and death are an interesting entry point for American students
studying the Nicaraguan Sandinista Revolution. Much of the material
for the activity can be found in the book, The
Death of Ben Linder. Students answer questions as they take
on different roles (as members of the press) and in the end they can
create a publication of their own.
Further questions about the Ben Linder Mystery before you begin...
Why it is important to study Ben Linder?
Why is this a WebQuest?
What is the purpose of this activity?
|
Introduction
back to top
|
|
To find out who Ben Linder was read this excerpt from
the Washington Post.
ON THE DAY OF BENJAMIN LINDER'S funeral, hundreds of chanting
people marched with his casket in Matagalpa, a Nicaraguan city in
the country's northern war zone. The Linder family walked near the
head of the crowd, dazed by the heat of the day and the event. Just
hours before, the Linders had stepped off a plane from Oregon into
Nicaragua's fervid April sun, and they now found themselves suddenly
embroiled in this noisy, equally fervid tribute to Ben, the first
American killed by the contras.
|
| Goals |
|
Goals of this activity:
- Increasing sensitivity through a personal approach. Students
are encouraged to stand in someone else's shoes through role play.
- Increasing critical thinking through asking students to examine
several sources about the same event and not just relay on the
account of one.
- Developing a critical mind through encouraging students to question
political policy
|
Quest(ion)
back to top |
|
Who was Ben Linder and what happened
to him?
|
Background
back
to top
|
|
As a group,
the team should look through these websites to get an overview of
who Ben Linder was and how the issues surrounding his death.
Ben Linder Sites:
The Death
of Ben Linder
Book Review:
The
Death of Ben Linder The Story of a North American in Sandinista
Nicaragua By Joan Kruckewitt
The Oregonian:
Longtime
Portland activist David Linder dies at 75 The pathologist's mission
to help the poor in Nicaragua, where his son, Ben, was killed by
Contras in 1987, will continue, family members say
U.S. Relations with the Sandinistas:
CIA
Report on the U.S. Foreign Relations with the Sandinistas
|
Individual
Roles
back to top
|
|
| Role: |
Goal:
|
| Photojournalist |
to
examine evidence from photographs about Ben Linder |
| International
press |
to review what the
international press reported about Ben Linder. |
| National
press |
to review
what the national press reported about Ben Linder. |
| Local
press |
to review
what the local press reported about Ben Linder. |
| Diary
archivist |
to review
Ben Linder's personal documents including parts of his diary |
| Government
agent |
to write
about the U.S. position on the Contras and their mission |
Now that students
have chosen which roles they will take, they are ready to become
an expert. Dossiers have been prepared for
each role. These contain guided instructions that should help you
Click on the name of your role to receive the Dossier
Resources
Using
Primary Source Materials A Guide for Students
How
to View a Photograph A Guide for Students
|
Group
Process
back to top |
|
The
student publication could be created in a Word Processing program
(such as Microsoft Word), a page layout program (such as ClarisWorks
or Pagemaker), or could be a website.
An effective
publication could include at least
- one editorial
essay
- a bibliography
- and can
answer the following questions after examining the evidence to
demonstrate an understanding of the content.
- Who was
Ben Linder and what happened to him?
- Where and
when did it happen? What kind of place was El Cuá?
- What were
the conditions like for him (and others) working on his project
in Nicaragua?
- Who were
the Sandinistas? What was their relationship to Ben Linder?
- Who were
the Contras? What was their relationship to Ben Linder?
- Define the
terms: sandinista, contra, "freedom-fighters"
- How can
we benefit by studying the death of Ben Linder?
- What does
studying this topic mean to you personally?
- Imagine
for a moment that you work with Ben at a co-op in Nicaragua. What
would that experience be like?
|
Evaluation/
Feedback
back to top |
|
The
methods below suggested how the goals mentioned earlier can be assessed.
The forms of assessment can be used to assess learning of the content
as well as the affective learning goal of increasing cultural understanding.
Students' Increased Understanding of Content
Suggested
Forms of Assessment
Student Self-Assessment
- Through
having to explain their perspective to another, students self-assess
their own understanding.
Student Peer-Assessment
- Students
assess each other's understanding of their perspectives through
their discussions while role-playing
Teacher Assessment
- Teachers
can use the rubric to assess the student publication.
Evaluation Rubric
- Teachers
may use this suggested rubric to assess student collaboration
Student
Collaboration Rubric
- You may
also ask your students to participate in creating a rubric.
How
to create a rubric WITH your students. Read here about empowering
students through negotiable contracting to draft rubrics for authentic
assessment
Why rubrics? Read here about why rubrics are used.
Students' Increased Cultural Sensitivity
- To evaluate
how students are increasing their cultural understanding or awareness
through this activity, pay close attention to the language students
use in communicating with each other, in their presentations,
and in their brochures. The best way to measure their increased
sensitivity is through knowing your students and finding out what
their feelings are before the activity begins. You may start by
asking students what their perceptions are of Nicaragua at first
and then follow through by asking students to write a letter to
a Nicaraguan (muralist, teacher, etc.). Once our e-pals area is
complete, there will be contacts in Central America for students
to send their letters to bringing authenticity to the task of
letter writing.
For this activity it would be appropriate to ask students to imagine
they work with Ben at a co-op in Nicaragua. What would that experience
be like?
|
Conclusion
back to top |
|
We hope that
by being a part of the Linder Mystery students gained an insider's
perspective of what it would be like to live and work in Nicaragua
during the Sandinista Revolution.
|
Glossary
back to top |
|
|
|
|
|
anti-
Sandinista guerrillas funded by the U.S. Government |
|
|
|
|
a
collection of papers containing detailed information about a
particular person or subject (usually a person's record) |
| FSLN |
Sandinista
National Liberation Front (in Spanish, Frente Sandinista de
Liberacion Nacional) |
|
Solidarity
Worker
|
people working together for the benefit of all the people, and
not just for one person in particular |
|
|
a
Nicaraguan guerrilla group that overthrew Anastasio Somoza Debayle
in 1979; named for CÈsar Augusto Sandino, a hero of Nicaraguan
resistance to U.S. military occupation (1927-33) |
|