twenty
years is starting to give us a detailed picture of how both similarities
and differences between the indigenous communities responded in the
sixth century, and of the tensions between novelty and traditionalism
in material culture.
If
we are to understand the political and economic dimensions of this
phenomenon we need to know a lot more about the city of Segesta. Vincenzo
Tusas pioneering fieldwork has not been followed up by excavations
in the archaic/classical settlement on Monte Barbaro; this is a top
priority. We also need more high-quality survey work. In an important
recent essay, Stefano Vassallo has suggested that the sixth century
saw both a demographic boom and rising standards of living. Better
survey data will test his first claim, but to examine the second we
need more quantified data from other sites, and particularly from
pre-sixth-century settlements.
To
understand more about the social dimensions of Hellenization, we need
more large-scale but detailed excavations on inland sites. Historians
studies of early modern Europe have found that the concentration of
power and wealth in state offices was normally accompanied by changes
in the distribution of power and wealth within villages and households.
We know very little at this point about rich and poor, gender, or
indeed any other social relationships in inland Sicily. By giving
us high-quality data from several parts of a single site, Monte Polizzo
could make a great contribution here. But as when discussing economic
changes, to make sense of the Monte Polizzo data we will also need
quantified comparisons with other settlements, especially earlier
ones.
The
abandonment processes at Monte Polizzo may be one of the most interesting
issues of all. Vassallo has noted that 62 percent of the sites in
western Sicily that were occupied around 550 BC had been abandoned
by 450. He argued that inland western Sicily flourished in the sixth
century by taking advantage of its position between the Greek and
Phoenician cities to supply both, but that the battle of Himera in
480 BC disrupted this delicate equilibrium, leading to economic disaster
and a demographic collapse. In some ways Monte Polizzo fits this theory
well; in other ways, less well. Zone A at Monte Polizzo was in use
till 475 or even 450, but House I burned down around 525, and C1 may
have burned even earlier, around 550. Few of the sites available to
Vassallo have been extensively excavated, but the picture is clearly
quite complicated. We urgently need better data on the abandonment
process. It is also hard to explain Segestas status in the fifth
century if there had really been an economic collapse in the 470s.
In the 420s Segesta could start an even more impressive temple, in
415 could fool the Athenians into believing that it was rich enough
to fund a major invasion of Sicily, and in 410 the promise of greater
influence at Segesta drew Carthage into a major war. In our 2002 preliminary
report we suggest that Monte Polizzos abandonment may have been
part of a gradual contraction of settlement onto Erice, the unidentified
Halikyai, and especially Segestanone of which is well known
in this periodand that Elymian social change and state-formation
may have followed a path like that of Syracuse under the Deinomenids
in the 480s-460s and the Sicels under Ducetius in the 450s-440s, where
there were forcible population transfers to the urban center.
Vassallo
makes the important point that during this fifth-century period when
evidence is so scarce outside Segesta, the indigenous traditions of
incised and stamped and matt-painted pottery (and we might also add
the hut-shrines) died out. When Monte Polizzo and many other inland
hill sites were reoccupied around 350, the finds are overwhelmingly
Greek and Punic. If we are right about the link between Segestan state-formation
and the abandonment of rural sites like Monte Polizzo, then this is
crucial to understanding Hellenization. Segestas success in
resisting Selinunte across the sixth and fifth centuries destroyed
other centers of Elymian culture, eventually creating something entirely
new: a Hellenized Sicilian city.
Bibliography
Indigenous
sites
Colle
Madore
Stefano
Vassallo, ed., Colle Madore: un caso di ellenizzazione in terra
sicana (Palermo 1999)
Entella
Giuseppe
Nenci, Entella, in AA.VV., Di terra in terra: nuove
scoperte archeologiche nella provincia di Palermo (Palermo 1991)
31-37
Raimondo
Guglielmino, Materiali arcaici e problemi di ellenizzazione
ad Entella, in Seconde giornate internazionali di studi sullarea
Elima, Atti III (Pisa-Gibellina 1997) 923-77
Montagnoli
Giuseppe
Castellana, Linsediamento di Montagnoli nei pressi di
Selinunte, Gli elimi e larea elima, ed. Giuseppe
Nenci, Sebastiano Tusa, and Vincenzo Tusa (Palermo 1988/89) 326-31
,
Note sulla ceramica indigena impressa proviente da scavi nella
valle del Belice e nel bacino finale del Platani, in Giornate
internazionali di studi sullarea Elima, Atti II (Pisa-Gibellina
1992) 191-202
,
Nuovi dati sull insediamento di Montagnoli presso Menfi,
in Terze Giornate internazionali di Studi sullarea elima,
Atti II (Pisa-Gibellina 2000) 263-71
Monte
Finestrelle
M.
De Cesare and M. Gargini, Monte Finestrelle di Gibellina: nota
preliminare sulla prima campagna di scavo, in Seconde giornate
internazionali di studi sullarea Elima, Atti I (Pisa-Gibellina
1997) 371-74
Monte
Maranfusa
Francesca
Spatafora, Monte Maranfusa (scavi 1986-87), in Gli
elimi e larea elima, ed. G. Nenci, S. Tusa, and V. Tusa
(Palermo 1988/1989) 293-99
,
Monte Maranfusa, in AA.VV., Di terra in terra: nuove
scoperte archeologiche nella provincia di Palermo (Palermo 1991)
2-12
,
Monte Maranfusa (campagna di scavo 1989), Kokalos
39-40 (1993-1994) 1199-1209
,
Tipologie abitative arcaiche nei centri indigeni occidentali:
il caso di Monte Maranfusa, in H-P. Isler, D. Käch, and
O. Stefani, eds., Wohnbauforschung in Zentral- und Westsizilien
(Zurich 1997) 151-64
Polizzello
Ernesto
De Miro, Gli indigeni della Sicilia centro-meridionale,
Kokalos 34/35 (1988-1989) 24-34
,
Lorganizzazione abitativa e dello spazio nei centri indigeni
delle valli del Salso e del Platani, in Magna Grecia e Sicilia:
stato degli studi e prospettive di ricerca, ed. M. Barra Bagnasco,
E. De Miro, and A. Pinzone (Messina 1999) 187-93
Sabucina
Ernesto
De Miro, Forme di contatto e processi di trasformazione nelle
società antiche: esempio da Sabucina, in AA.VV., Forme
di contatto e processi di trasformazione nelle società antiche
(Rome, Collection de lécole française de Rome
67, 1983) 335-44
R.
Mollo Mezzena, Sabucina, recenti scavi nellarea fuori
le mura, in Atti del convegno Storia e archeologia della
media e bassa valle dellHimera (Palermo 1993) 137-82
Segesta
Juliette
de la Genière, Alla ricerca di Segesta arcaica,
Annali di Scuola Normale Superiore di Pisa 3rd ser. 18 (1988)
287-316
Greeks,
Phoenicians, and natives in western Sicily
Pietrina
Anello, Il trattato del 405/4 a.C. e la formazione della eparchia
punica in Sicilia, Kokalos 32 (1986) 115-79
,
Rapporti dei Punici con Elimi, Sicani e Greci, Kokalos
34/35 (1990-1991) 175-213
,
Lo stato elimo nel VI e V sec. a. C., in Seconde
giornate internazionali di studi sullarea Elima, Atti I
(Pisa-Gibellina 1997) 41-76
Sandro
Bondì, Penetrazione fenicio-punica e storia della civiltà
punica in Sicilia, in La Sicilia antica I.1. Indigeni,
Fenici-Punici e Greci, ed. Emilio Gabba and Georges Vallet (Naples
1980) 163-225
,
Gli Elimi e il mondo fenicio-punico, in Gli elimi e
larea elima, ed. Giuseppe Nenci, Sebastiano Tusa, and Vincenzo
Tusa (Palermo 1988/89) 133-44
,
Contributi alla storia della Sicilia fenicio-punica, Kokalos
34/35 (1988-1989b) 407-425
Franco
De Angelis, Megara Hyblaia and Selinous: The Development of Two
Greek City-States in Archaic Sicily (Oxford 2002)
Luigi
Gallo, Alcune considerazioni sulla demografia degli Elimi,
Annali di Scuola Normale Superiore di Pisa 3rd ser. 24 (1994)
19-29
,
Per un riesame dei rapporti tra Segesta e Selinunte, in
Terze giornate internazionali di studi sullarea Elima, Atti
I (Pisa-Gibellina 2000) 517-31
Stefano
Vassallo, Abitati indigeni ellenizati della Sicilia centro-occidentale
dalla vitalità tardo-arcaica alla crisi del V sec. a.C.,
in Terze Giornate internazionali di Studi sullarea elima,
Atti II (Pisa-Gibellina 2000) 985-1008
State
formation
Jack
Goldstone, Revolution and Rebellion in the Early Modern World
(Berkeley 1991)
George
Steinmetz, ed., State/Culture: State-Formation After the Cultural
Turn (Ithaca, NY, 1999)
Michael
Braddick, State-Formation in Early Modern England, c. 1550-1700
(Cambridge 2000)
Pottery
Francesca
Spatafora, La ceramica indigena a decorazione impressa e incisa
nella Sicilia centro-occidentale: diffusione e pertinenza etnica,
Sicilia Archeologica 29 (1996) 91-110
Caterina
Trombi, La ceramica indigena dipinta della Sicilia dalla seconda
metà del IX sec. a. C. al V sec. a. C., in Magna Grecia
e Sicilia: stato degli studi e prospettive di ricerca, ed. M.
Barra Bagnasco, E. De Miro, and A. Pinzone (Messina 1999) 275-93
Di
Noto, C. A. 1995. La ceramica indigena a decorazione geometrica
incisa ed impressa. In Giuseppe Nenci, ed., Entella I:
77-110. Pisa: Scuola Normale Superiore.
Houses
Anne
Cordsen, The pastas house in archaic Greek Sicily, Acta
Hyperborea 6 (1995) 103-121
Francesco
DAndria and Katia Mannino, eds., Ricerche sulla casa in Magna
Graecia e Sicilia (Lecce 1996)
H-P.
Isler, D. Käch, and O. Stefani, eds., Wohnbauforschung in
Zentral- und Westsizilien (Zurich 1997)
Lisa
Nevett, House and Society in the Ancient Greek World (Cambridge
1999)
Religion
Ilaria
Romeo, Sacelli arcaici senza peristasi nella Sicilia greca,
Xenia 17 (1989) 5-54
Anthony
Snodgrass, Interaction by design: the Greek city-states,
in Colin Renfrew and John Cherry, eds., Peer Polity Interaction
and the Development of Socio-Cultural Complexity (Cambridge 1986)
47-58
Surveys
V.
Alliata, O. Belvedere, A. Cantoni, G. Cusimano, P. Maresalchi, and
Stefano Vassallo, Himera III: prospezione archeologica nel
territorio (Rome 1988).
O.
Belvedere Prospezione archeologica nella valle dImera.
Kokalos 34/35 (1988/89) 659-68
Sandra
Bernardini, Franco Cambi, Alessandra Molinari, and Ilaria Neri, Il
territorio di Segesta fra letà arcaica e il medioevo,
in Terze giornate internazionali di studi sullarea Elima,
Atti I (Pisa-Gibellina 2000) 91-133
R.
Bianchi, R. M. Cavalli, F. Colosi, M. C. Conti, C. M. Marino, S. Pignatti,
S. Pino, M. Poscolieri, L. Versino, and C. Zoppi, Selinunte
IV (Rome 1998).
Maria
Giovanna Canzanella, Primi dati di ricognizione al suolo nella
regione di Entella, in Giornate internazionali di studi sullarea
Elima, Atti I (Pisa-Gibellina 1992)151-72
Jeremy
Johns, Monreale survey: linsediamento umano nellalto
Belice dalletà paleolitica al 1250 d. C., in Seconde
giornate internazionali di studi sullarea Elima, Atti I
(Pisa-Gibellina 1997) 407-420
Francesca
Spatafora, Lalta e media valle del Belice tra la media
del Età del Bronzo e letà arcaica, Kokalos
42 (1996) 177-98
,
Ricerche e prospezioni nel territorio di Corleone: insediamenti
preistorici e centri indigeni, in Seconde gionate internazionali
di studi sull area elima, Atti III (Pisa-Gibellina 1997)
1273-86
Stefano
Vassallo, Il territorio di Himera in età arcaica,
Kokalos 42 (1996) 199-223
Michael
Kolb and Sebastiano Tusa, The Late Bronze Age and Early Iron
Age landscape of interior western Sicily, Antiquity 75
(2001) 503-504
Leah
Stevens-Block and Pierfrancesco Vecchio, Landscape analysis
of rural valley settlement patterns in western Sicily. Paper
delivered at the 67th annual meeting of the Society for American Archaeology,
Denver, Colorado, March 23rd, 2002