Class questions:
- Give one example of "mental reservation" and one of "equivocation"
(see notes from class 1)
- Would a completely truthful society be any more tolerable than a completely
mendacious one?
- Evaluate Shapins claims for the
reliance of modern scientist on trust in authorities, with regard to a specific
example.
- Give one example of the modernist transition described by Shapin
from trust in people to trust in impersonal systems.
- Are geometrical truths, as Barnes seems to suggest, dependent on trusting
people? What would it be like to distrust the Pythagorean theorem?
- Compare St. Augustines analysis
of lying in medical practice with that of Lawrence Henderson (see notes
from class 1)
Bonus question (optional):
Would Kants moral critique of lying (see notes
from class 2), apply to mental reservation and equivocation?